SarkariResultOutVidyut Sahayak (Junior Engineer - Electrical) · 2024

Previous Year Question

Which protection is employed for generator rating from 1 MVA to 5 MVA?
  1. Phase unbalance
  2. Time graded earth fault
  3. Balanced earth fault
  4. Time graded over current

Correct answer: C

Explanation

C — Balanced earth fault. This is the protection scheme associated with the 1–5 MVA generator range in the supplied paper.

Formula

KEY RELATION / LOGIC: Under healthy or external-fault conditions, the residual of the phase CT currents balances the neutral CT current; an internal earth fault produces differential relay current.

Step-by-step solution

Correct answer: C — Balanced earth fault

How balanced earth-fault protection operates

Balanced earth-fault protection detects earth faults inside a defined generator protection zone. In a typical arrangement, the residual current obtained from the three phase current transformers is compared with the current measured by a neutral current transformer. CT ratios, polarities and connections are selected so that the relay currents balance for healthy operation and faults outside the protected zone.

For normal balanced operation, the phasor sum of the three line currents is approximately zero. During an external earth fault, the corresponding phase-residual and neutral-current signals should balance at the relay. Little operating current therefore flows through its measuring element.

An earth fault within the CT-defined zone disturbs this balance. A difference or spill current flows through the relay, which initiates tripping when its operating threshold is exceeded. The protected zone and sensitivity depend on the actual CT arrangement and generator neutral-earthing system.

The examination associates this relatively economical scheme with generators rated 1 MVA to 5 MVA. The rating range is a textbook selection guide, not a universal design rule. Real generator protection is selected using winding arrangements, earthing, fault-current levels, required coverage and coordination.

Other options

A is aimed at phase unbalance/negative-sequence conditions. B and D are time-graded overcurrent/earth-fault approaches and are less specifically matched to the keyed small-generator internal earth-fault scheme. C is the source-keyed scheme.

Common mistake

Assuming ‘balanced earth fault’ means the fault itself is balanced; the word refers to the protection scheme’s current balance.

Exam tip

Generator protection questions often distinguish selective differential/earth-fault schemes from backup time-graded overcurrent schemes.

Quick method

Internal stator earth fault → look for a differential/balanced earth-fault scheme.