This question was asked inGPSC Deputy Executive Engineer (Electrical) Class-2 Master Paper 2026Question 114 of 195 published · Gujarat Public Service CommissionOpen paper
Q114HardLoad Flow

पावर सिस्टम में लोड फ्लो अध्ययन के संबंध में निम्नलिखित कथनों पर विचार कीजिए:
1. बस एडमिटेंस मैट्रिक्स एक विरल (sparse) मैट्रिक्स है।
2. लोड फ्लो अध्ययन के लिए गॉस-सीडल विधि को न्यूटन-रैफसन विधि से अधिक पसंद किया जाता है।
3. लोड फ्लो अध्ययन में एक बस को स्लैक बस लिया जाता है।
इनमें से कौन-से कथन सही हैं?

उत्तर और चरणबद्ध हल
सही उत्तर: B. केवल 1 और 3
संक्षिप्त व्याख्या

B — केवल 1 और 3। Ybus विरल है क्योंकि प्रत्येक बस कुछ ही बसों से जुड़ी है, और एक बस को स्लैक बस लिया जाता है। बड़ी प्रणालियों के लिए न्यूटन-रैफसन तेज़ अभिसरण के कारण पसंद की जाती है, गॉस-सीडल नहीं।

विस्तृत हल (मूल भाषा में)

Statement-wise Verification

  • Statement 1 - Correct.
    Bus admittance matrix is a sparse matrix
    Each bus connects directly to only a small fraction of all buses, so Ybus contains many zeros and is sparse.
  • Statement 2 - Incorrect.
    Gauss-Seidel method is preferred over Newton-Raphson method for load flow Studies
    As a general engineering statement: Newton-Raphson has stronger convergence and fewer iterations for large systems; Gauss-Seidel is simple but slower and more sensitive to the initial guess.
  • Statement 3 - Correct.
    One of the buses is taken as slack bus in load flow studies
    A slack bus fixes voltage magnitude/angle reference and absorbs the mismatch in real/reactive power caused by network losses and solution balance.

Core Concept

Load flow solves nonlinear algebraic power-balance equations. Bus types are slack, PV and PQ. Sparse matrix structure is exploited computationally, especially in large networks.

Formula / Key Relationship

P_i=Σ|V_i||V_k||Y_ik|cos(δ_i−δ_k−θ_ik); Q_i=Σ|V_i||V_k||Y_ik|sin(δ_i−δ_k−θ_ik).

Step-by-Step Check

Network topology establishes sparsity; standard load-flow formulation requires a reference/slack bus; algorithm comparison rejects the blanket preference for Gauss-Seidel. Option B.

Why the Other Options Are Wrong

Option A is incorrect because it includes incorrect statement(s) 2. Option C is incorrect because it includes incorrect statement(s) 2 and omits correct statement(s) 3. Option D is incorrect because it includes incorrect statement(s) 2 and omits correct statement(s) 1.

Answer-Key Verification Note

The uploaded provisional key marks D . After independent technical verification, the defensible answer is B . This discrepancy is stated explicitly rather than silently copying the provisional key.

Exam Shortcut / Approach

Large-system default in exams: NR is faster/robust; GS is simpler but slower.

Common Mistake

Thinking the slack bus has specified P and Q; those are outputs after the load-flow solution.

Quick Revision

Ybus Slack Bus and Numerical Methods is linked with Load Flow Methods, Load Flow and Power Systems. Large-system default in exams: NR is faster/robust; GS is simpler but slower.

Verified · SRO editorial desk Report
Try it before reading the solution — tap an option.0/1✓ 0✗ 0

More Load Flow questions