SarkariResultOutVidyut Sahayak (Junior Engineer - Electrical) · 2024

Previous Year Question

In Comparison between SVC and STATCOM which of the following statements is correct?
  1. SVC has a larger dynamic range and STATCOM has a smaller dynamic voltage.
  2. STATCOM acts as a voltage source behind a reactance and SVC acts as a variable susceptance.
  3. SVC has faster response and better performance during transients and STATCOM has Somewhat slower response
  4. STATCOM has higher generation of harmonics and SVC has lower generation of harmonics

Correct answer: B

Explanation

B — A STATCOM acts as a voltage source behind a reactance, while an SVC acts as a variable susceptance.

Formula

QSVC = V²B
ISTATCOM = (E − V)/(jX), for aligned voltage phasors

Step-by-step solution

Correct answer: B — STATCOM acts as a voltage source behind a reactance and SVC acts as a variable susceptance.

SVC: variable shunt susceptance

A Static Var Compensator (SVC) regulates reactive power using shunt capacitor and reactor branches controlled or switched by thyristors. Its fundamental-frequency equivalent is a controllable susceptance B connected to the bus. With capacitive injection defined as positive:

QSVC = V²B

At the limit of available capacitive susceptance, its maximum capacitive VAR output falls approximately with the square of bus voltage. This is an important limitation during a deep voltage reduction.

STATCOM: controllable voltage behind reactance

A STATCOM uses a voltage-source converter connected to the network through coupling reactance. If its converter voltage E is approximately in phase with bus voltage V, the voltage-magnitude difference drives reactive current:

I = (E − V)/(jX)

If E is greater than V, the STATCOM supplies capacitive reactive power to the bus. If E is smaller than V, it absorbs reactive power. The coupling reactance X limits and controls this current exchange.

A STATCOM can maintain approximately its rated reactive current over part of its low-voltage operating range, subject to converter limits. Its reactive power still decreases with voltage because Q is proportional to VI. The decisive distinction in this question is the equivalent model: variable susceptance for SVC; voltage source behind reactance for STATCOM.

Other options

A reverses the usual dynamic-performance comparison. C is incorrect because STATCOM is not the slower device. D is also opposite to the usual comparison; converter switching does create harmonics, but modern STATCOMs are not characterized simply as having ‘higher harmonics’ than SVCs as a defining advantage/disadvantage.

Common mistake

Assuming both devices are just variable capacitors. Their circuit models and low-voltage VAR characteristics are fundamentally different.

Exam tip

Use the equivalent-circuit model to answer SVC-versus-STATCOM questions instead of memorizing isolated statements.

Quick method

SVC → B (susceptance); STATCOM → V-source.